What should I get my boyfriend for Easter?

My boyfriend and I have been together for about 3 weeks. Easter is this weekend and he already bought presents for me. He bought two of them, but he has given me 3 presents already: a stuffed bunny, his Invader Zim blanket (Gir), and a cartoon drawing he drew for me. This Saturday he is giving me my big present, and I have no clue what it is, I just know that it's a stuffed animal. The thing is that I have no clue what to give him! My mom says we should make him an Easter basket, but when I think of Easter baskets, I think of candy and stuff. My boyfriend isn't much of an eater. He doesn't eat lunch at school, and sometimes he will go without eating dinner. He only eats snacks. He's not man-orexic/annorexic or anything. So what do you think I should get my boyfriend for Easter? And don't answer "sex" because I'm not that kind of person. And it has to be something I can buy for under 25-30 dollars at WalMart.